1992: Moose Jaw Breakers (Cascadia) defeated Portland Grizzlies (San Antonio)  2-1

1993: Indianapolis Icers defeated Hamilton Mounties (Greenwich) 3-2

1994: Portland Grizzlies (San Antonio) swept Indianapolis Icers 3-0

1995: Music City Marauders defeated Portland Grizzlies (San Antonio) 3-2

1996: Portland Grizzlies (San Antonio) defeated Halifax Frozen Cardinals 3-1

1997: San Diego Sun Devils (Washington) defeated Music City Marauders 3-2

1998: Halifax Frozen Cardinals swept San Diego Sun Devils (Victoria) 3-0

1999: San Diego Sun Devils (Washington) defeated Halifax Frozen Cardinals 3-2

2000: Indianapolis Icers defeated Portland Ice Penguins (San Antonio) 3-2

2001: San Diego Sun Devils (Washington) defeated Halifax Frozen Cardinals 3-2

2002: San Diego Sun Devils (Washington) defeated Music City Marauders 3-1

2003: Music City Marauders defeated Moose Jaw Breakers (Cascadia) 3-1

2004: Indianapolis Icers defeated Island Surf Riders 3-1

2005: NHL Lockout–Cup not awarded

2006: Greenwich Goonz defeated San Diego Sun Devils (Victoria) 3-2

2007: Greenwich Goonz defeated Vancouver Dragoons (San Antonio) 3-1

2008: Music City Marauders swept Island Surf Riders 3-0

2009: Island Surf Riders swept Greenwich Goonz 3-0

2010: Victoria Vigilantes (Washington) defeated Music City Marauders 3-2

2011: Halifax Frozen Cardinals defeated Ocean Beach Cliff Bangers (San Antonio) 3-2

2012: Music City Marauders swept Victoria Vigilantes (Warriors) 3-0

2013: Halifax Frozen Cardinals swept Victoria Vigilantes (Warriors) 3-0

2014: Music City Marauders defeated Victoria Vigilantes (Warriors) 3-1

2015: Island Surf Riders defeated Music City Marauders 3-2

2016: Victoria Vigilantes (Washington) defeated Music City Marauders 3-2

2017: San Antonio Diablos defeated Indianapolis Icers 3-1

2018: Music City Marauders defeated Cascadia Ice Crushers 3-1

2019: Indianapolis Icers swept El Paso Bobcats 3-0

2020: Playoffs not completed because of COVID-19 pandemic–Cup not awarded

2021: San Antonio Diablos defeated Halifax Frozen Cardinals 3-2

2022: Albuquerque Ice Pack defeated Indianapolis Icers 3-1

2023: Indianapolis Icers defeated San Antonio Diablos 3-1



















2024: Music City Marauders defeated Island Surf Riders 3-1